Confused between Whole Earth Farms vs Blue Buffalo? In general, both brands are considered as good quality dog foods. They use real meats and beneficial vegetables to give complete nutrition to your dog. Below, you can read the detailed comparison between Whole Earth Farms and Blue Buffalo, which will help you determine the best one for your dog.
Continue reading below to learn more about:
– The evaluation of the ingredients used by Whole Earth Farms
– The evaluation of the ingredients used by Blue Buffalo
– The comparison of their nutrition
– The recall history of each dog food
– The formulas of Whole Earth Farms vs Blue Buffalo
– Which dog food that is generally more recommended
Ingredients of Whole Earth Farms
It is required that product labels list their ingredients in a certain order, from the highest amount to the lowest amount. By checking the main ingredients of a dog food, we can estimate the quality. Good ingredients make good dog foods. Bad ingredients, such as fillers and artificial substances, are bad for your dog. See also: Whole Earth Farms vs Merrick.
The first ingredients of Whole Earth Farms include pork meal, pork fat, dried potatoes, sweet potatoes, peas, natural pork flavor, pork, lamb, beef, organic alfalfa meal, yeast culture, salmon oil, salt, as well as some added vitamins and minerals. There are also some other plant-based ingredients like dried blueberries, cinnamon, and rosemary along with prebiotics, but these ones come in smaller amounts.
In general, the ingredient quality of Whole Earth Farms vs Blue Buffalo is good. This dog food does not have many real meats. It is not geared towards a meat-focused diet. The formula is more balanced and suitable for most modern dogs. Nevertheless, there are some nice real meats, such as pork, lamb, and beef. These real meats are excellent sources of protein.
Peas and potatoes are excellent sources of carbohydrates. They also provide healthy dietary fiber. Alfalfa meal provides some plant-based protein and dietary fiber, too. Salmon oil contains DHA and EPA, both of which belong to the omega-3 fatty acid group and are beneficial for your dog’s health. The dried fermentation products and prebiotics aid in improving and maintaining the digestive health.
Ingredients of Blue Buffalo
Meanwhile, the first ingredients of Blue Buffalo include chicken meal, deboned chicken, chicken fat, brown rice, oatmeal, barley, peas, flaxseed, tomato pomace, natural flavor, alfalfa meal, potatoes, and some added vitamins and minerals. Blue Buffalo also uses caramel, garlic, and dried yeast. Most of these ingredients are good.
The good thing about this dog food is that it uses real meat. Chicken, deboned chicken, and chicken fat are highly beneficial for dogs. In addition, there are grains and vegetables that provide carbohydrates, dietary fiber, and B vitamins. Flaxseed is rich in omega-3 fatty acids. However, there are some ingredients that aren’t very good.
Tomato pomace, while having high fiber and decent nutrition, is widely considered as a cheap filler for a pet food. Also, the total protein content may be composed of a high amount of plant-based protein. While plant-based proteins are also beneficial for dogs, proteins from real meats can be digested more easily.
Caramel is a coloring agent, but some studies have found that caramel may increase the risk of cancer in lab animals. Garlic, in a high amount, may cause Heinz anemia on dogs. Dried yeast is rich of protein and other nutrients; it can help to support the immune system. But some dogs may be allergic to dried yeast.
Now, we are going to compare the nutritional values of Whole Earth Farms vs Blue Buffalo. The numbers are generally comparable, with just marginal differences. Still, Whole Earth Farms holds a slightly better edge over Blue Buffalo.
Whole Earth Farms contains 29% protein, 15% fat, and 48% carbohydrate on a dry matter basis. Compared to Blue Buffalo, Whole Earth Farms comes with slightly higher protein. The fat is just a tad lower. The lower carbohydrate is not really a bad thing because protein is the most important nutrient for a dog.
Blue Buffalo contains 27% protein, 16% fat, and 50% carbohydrate on a dry matter basis. As you can see, this dog food is lower in protein while having slightly more fat and carbohydrate. The higher amounts of fat and carbohydrate make up the calories. But the lower protein content is still a minor disadvantage.
When choosing a dog food, you may want to check the company’s track record before actually buying the product. If a dog food has faced lots of problems in the recent past, we may suspect that the quality control isn’t good.Dog foods with clean track records are generally trustworthy.
Whole Earth Farms is great because it has a clean track record. It hasn’t been recalled since it was introduced into the market. The quality control is good, so let’s hope it will remain clean for the years to come.
Blue Buffalo has been recalled several times in the past. It was recalled twice in 2007, once in 2010, twice in 2015, once in 2016, and twice in 2017. The most recent recalls were because of aluminum contamination and a foil seal packaging defect.
Whole Earth Farms is available in several formulas. Some of them use different types of meat to provide different flavors. There are also some formulas for specific purposes, such as formulas for puppies and formulas small breeds. Popular examples include:
– Whole Earth Farms with Turkey & Duck
– Whole Earth Farms with Chicken & Turkey
– Whole Earth Farms with Salmon & Whitefish
– Whole Earth Farms with Pork, Beef, Lamb
– Whole Earth Farms Healthy Weight Adult
– Whole Earth Farms Small Breed
– Whole Earth Farms Small Breed with Salmon & Whitefish
– Whole Earth Farms Small Breed with Pork, Beef, Lamb
– Whole Earth Farms Puppy All Breeds
Blue Buffalo has a wide range of formulas. Some of the most popular ones are:
– Blue Buffalo Chicken for Adult
– Blue Buffalo Chicken and Brown Rice for Adult
– Blue Buffalo Chicken and Brown Rice for Large Breed Adult
– Blue Buffalo Fish and Oatmeal for Large Breed Adult
– Blue Buffalo Fish and Brown Rice for Small Breed Adult
– Blue Buffalo Lamb and Brown Rice for Small Breed Adult
– Blue Buffalo Chicken for Puppy
– Blue Buffalo Lamb and Oatmeal for Puppy
– Blue Buffalo Chicken and Brown Rice for Puppy
– Blue Buffalo Chicken and Brown Rice for Large Breed Puppy
– Blue Buffalo Chicken and Oatmeal for Small Breed Puppy
Whole Earth Farms vs Blue Buffalo
|Whole Earth Farms||Blue Buffalo|
|- Great quality ingredients with real meats and veggies||- Good quality ingredients, but some controversial ingredients|
|- Slightly higher protein||- Slightly lower protein|
|- Slightly lower fat and carbohydrate||- Slightly higher fat and carbohydrate|
|- Hasn’t been recalled||- Has been recalled several times in the last few years|
Between these two dog foods, Whole Earth Farms is more recommended. This dog food uses better quality ingredients and provides slightly better nutrition, with a higher amount of protein. It also has a better track record as it hasn’t been recalled because of any problem.