If you are confused between Orijen vs Zignature, you have come to the right place! In this article, we will discuss the comparison between these two high-quality dog foods based on several aspects. Both Orijen and Zignature have lots of positive reviews and impressive ratings from their users, but there are still notable differences that you should consider before choosing.
What we are going to discuss in this article include:
– The ingredients used by each dog food
– The comparison of their nutritional values
– The history of recalls on each brand
– The available formulas on Orijen vs Zignature
– Which dog food that is generally more recommended
The Ingredients of Orijen
Most if not all people agree that one of the most important aspects of a dog food is the ingredients. Why? Well, the nutrition of the dog food comes from the ingredients. Without a good ingredient quality, you can’t have a good dog food. See also: Zignature vs Taste Of The Wild.
Orijen is trusted by many dog owners not for nothing. The ingredient quality of this dog food is very impressive. The first ingredients listed in the label, which are the ones that come in the highest amounts, are all real meats and highly nutritious vegetables.
The first ingredients of Orijen include deboned chicken, deboned turkey, flounder, whole atlantic mackerel, whole atlantic herring, chicken liver, chicken heart, turkey liver, turkey heart, whole navy beans, whole green peas, pinto beans, chickpeas, red lentils, green lentils, and lentil fiber. There are lots of real meats, which are excellent protein sources for dogs.
Chicken and turkey are obviously great for dogs. There are some body parts which provide quality protein, B vitamins, and minerals. Flounder, mackerel, and herring are high in protein. The plant-based ingredients provide carbohydrates and fiber. Perhaps the only not-so-good ingredient in this dog food is lentil fiber, which only provides fiber without any other nutritional value.
The Ingredients of Zignature
Zignature is also considered as a good dog food brand by many people. However, if we compare the ingredient quality of Orijen vs Zignature, we may find that Zignature is at a slight disadvantage. It doesn’t have as many real meat ingredients, and it uses more plant-based protein sources. Plant-based ingredients are fine for dogs, but they are not exactly as good as real meats.
The first ingredients of Zignature include salmon meal, trout, salmon meal, natural flavors, peas, pea flour, chickpeas, dehydrated alfalfa meal, flaxseed, sunflower oil, and dried beet pulp. There are also a bunch of added vitamins and minerals, which may indicate that the base ingredients aren’t sufficient for providing those vitamins and minerals.
Salmon meal and trout are real meats and are excellent protein sources. Peas, chickpeas, and alfalfa meal are good sources of fiber. Salmon oil and flaxseed are rich of omega-3 fatty acids. Sunflower oil provides omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids. However, a large amount of the protein is apparently supplied by pea flour and alfalfa meal, which are plant-based ingredients and are less absorbed by a dog’s digestive system.
Now, let’s take a look at the nutrition comparison of Orijen vs Zignature. Dogs certainly need a variety of nutrients, including vitamins and minerals. However, there are three essential types of nutrients that are often compared on dog foods because they are the major macronutrients: protein, fat, and carbohydrate.
Protein is incredibly essential for dogs. There are actually many types of protein, which provide different amino acids once digested. A dog needs 22 different amino acids to survive. Twelve of them can be naturally produced in the dog’s body. Ten of them can only be acquired from foods.
Orijen contains 43% protein on dry matter basis. Zignature contains 33% protein on dry matter basis. The difference is quite significant here. Orijen is definitely better in terms of protein content.
Fat is also important for dogs. Fats provide fatty acids that are needed for some bodily functions. On dry matter basis, Orijen contains 21% fat, while Zignature contains 16% fat. Once again, Orijen has turned out to be better than Zignature, this time in terms of fat content.
Carbohydrate is also important for dogs. It is a source of energy. However, it is not as important as protein because it does not provide the necessary amino acids. Orijen only has 28% carbohydrate on dry matter basis. This is fine. Zignature has a high amount of carbohydrate, which is 43% on dry matter basis. The high carbohydrate content is apparently used to increase the caloric count, as the protein and fat aren’t as high.
When comparing two brands of dog foods, we can check their history of recalls. This is to help in determining their quality control.
Orijen has only been recalled once in the past. It was in November 2008 – it’s been quite a long time since the incident. The recall was because of irradiation treatment. Nevertheless, Orijen hasn’t been recalled anymore since then. So, we can assume that the problem has been solved properly and the quality control has been kept in check.
Zignature hasn’t been recalled so far. This indicates that the quality control is good. Let’s hope that the track record remains clear in the years to come.
Orijen is available in several formulas. There are specific recipes for specific ages and breeds, and special formulas made for specific diets. Some popular examples are:
– Orijen Puppy
– Orijen Puppy Large
– Orijen Senior
– Orijen Original
– Orijen Tundra
– Orijen Six Fish
– Orijen Regional Red
– Orijen Fit and Trim
Zignature also provides a wide range of formulas. Some popular examples include:
– ZignatureZssential Formula
– Zignature Turkey Formula
– Zignature Duck Formula
– Zignature Pork Formula
– Zignature Kangaroo Formula
– Zignature Lamb Formula
– Zignature Venison Formula
– Zignature Trout and Salmon Formula
– Zignature Salmon Formula
– Zignature Whitefish Formula
– Zignature Catfish Formula
Orijen vs Zignature
|- Excellent ingredient quality||- Good ingredient quality|
|- Higher protein and fat||- Lower protein and fat|
|- Relatively low carbohydrate||- High carbohydrate content|
|- Was recalled once in 2008||- Hasn’t been recalled yet|
In general, Orijen is more recommended. This dog food has better ingredient quality. It also provides better nutrition with higher protein and fat.