Roughly 1 in 5 pet owners now use a pet food delivery service. Of course, we always want to give the best nutrition for our pets, so this is not surprising. Two of the most popular services right now are NomNomNow and Ollie. Below, you can read the comparison between NomNomNow vs Ollie to help you choose the best service.
Continue reading below to learn more about:
– The comparison of their packaging and shipment
– The available recipes on NomNomNow
– The available recipes on Ollie
– Nutrition personalization on NomNomNow vs Ollie
– The comparison of their pricing
– Which dog food delivery service that is generally better
Packaging and Shipment
Both services send their foods frozen with ice packs that keep the foods fresh and healthy. However, their packaging forms differ. NomNomNow is slightly better than Ollie because its packaging is easier to handle. See also: Canidae vs Zignature.
Foods from NomNomNow come very quickly. One impressive thing is that, although the foods are shipped by FedEx, they can arrive at your home within 12 hours since the moment they left the kitchen. The foods are fresh and frozen, packaged in small bags. You can put these small bags in warm water to heat the foods so that your dog can eat them.
The small plastic bags are easy to open. One bag is equal to one serving, so NomNomNow is very practical in terms of serving. You just need to squeeze the whole content of a bag into your dog’s bowl. When ordering multiple bags at once, the small plastic bags of NomNomNow vs Ollie are easy to stuff into your refrigerator.
Foods from Ollie also come quickly. They are also frozen. However, the foods come in trays rather than small bags. As the effect, you can’t put them under warm water to heat them up. Using a microwave may work, but you can just leave them in your refrigerator to let them thaw for a few hours before feeding them to your dog.
Each tray is covered with a plastic film. You just need to cut it open. Then, you can open the tray and pour the content into your dog’s bowl. However, stuffing multiple trays in your refrigerator may be a bit challenging, as they require quite some space.
Recipes on NomNomNow
NomNomNow is available in five recipes. The company is based in California, and it is focused on providing fresh dog meals with human-grade ingredients. The company claims that it doesn’t use any artificial preservative or filler. The nutrition is formulated by a vet nutritionist to tailor every dog’s specific needs. All of its meat ingredients are USDA-certified.
– Chicken Chow-Wow : This recipe consists of boneless chicken thigh mixed with fish oil, sweet potatoes, spinach, yellow squash, and NomNom Nutrient Mix.
– Heartland Beef Mash : This recipe consists of ground beef with eggs, fish oil, potatoes, peas, carrots, and NomNom Nutrient Mix.
– Tasty Turkey Fare: This recipe consists of ground turkey, eggs, fish oil, spinach, carrots, brown rice, and NomNom Nutrient Mix.
– Egg & Veggie Medley : This recipe consists of eggs, teff, tofu, green beans, mulberries, green beans, bamboo shoots, and NomNom Nutrient Mix.
– PorkaliciousPotluck : This recipe consists of pork, fish oil, zucchini, potatoes, mushrooms, kale, green bean, and NomNom Nutrient Mix.
Recipes on Ollie
Ollie is based in New York City. The nutrition is vet-formulated by using a unique algorithm that considers various factors, including the dog’s breed, age, and weight. In order to provide high-quality meals, the company uses human-grade meats, fruits, vegetables, and added nutrients. All of the meats are USDA-certified. There are four recipes currently available.
– Chicken Goodness : This recipe consists of chicken, eggs, fish oil, cod liver oil, chia seed, carrots, spinach, green peas, long grain rice, potatoes, blueberries sunflower oil, rosemary, iodized salt, calcium carbonate, vitamin E, vitamin B6, and vitamin B2.
– Tasty Lamb Fare : This recipe consists of lamb, cod liver oil, rutabaga, kale, cranberries, butternut squash, chickpeas, potatoes, strawberries, iodized salt, calcium carbonate, taurine, ferrous sulfate, and vitamin E.
– Healthy Turkey Feast : This recipe consists of turkey, cod liver oil, coconut oil, kale, lentils, chia seeds, blueberries, salt, ferrous sulfate, potassium iodate, and vitamin E.
– Hearty Beef Eats : This recipe consists of beef, fish oil, sweet potatoes, peas, carrots, spinach, chia seeds, blueberries, rosemary, basil, sunflower oil, iodized salt, calcium carbonate, vitamin E, vitamin B6, vitamin B12.
The next difference between NomNomNow vs Ollie is the customization. Well, they both can tailor their nutritional values to suit your dog’s needs. However, NomNomNow is slightly more precise and accurate than Ollie, especially when it comes to caloric count.
Whenever you place an order on NomNomNow, the company will ask you some questions such as your dog’s age, weight, and activity level. They will use this information to design the ideal caloric count in each meal. Every small bag contains one individual portion for your dog. So, there is no guesswork about how much to give the food to your dog.
You will also get similar questions when ordering from Ollie. They also design the nutritional values to suit your dog. However, the food comes in a tray, and you still need to scoop the food by yourself. Since one tray is not exactly equal to one serving, there is some guesswork here when determining how many calories to give your dog at a time.
If you are feeding an all NomNomNow diet with the Heartland Beef recipe to your dog, the weekly cost for 14 meals is about $50.59. So, the price is about $3.61 per meal. The Chicken Chow-Wow recipe is slightly more expensive at $56.00 per week or roughly $4.00 per meal.
Ollie is a bit more expensive. If you are feeding an all Ollie diet with the Hearty Beef Eats recipe, the weekly cost for 14 meals is about $59.98, or roughly $4.28 per meal. Meanwhile, with the Chicken Goodness recipe, the weekly cost is $80.36, which is equivalent to $5.74 per meal.
NomNomNow vs Ollie
|- Comes in small plastic bags
|- Comes in trays
|- One bag equals to one serving
|- One tray may have more than one serving
|- Available in five recipes
|- Available in four recipes
|- Better customization to suit your dog’s needs
|- Good customization to suit your dog’s needs
|- Relatively more affordable
|- Slightly more expensive
In general, NomNomNow is more recommended. This dog food delivery service comes in small plastic bags that are easier to store. Each bag is equal to one serving, so there is no guesswork when determining the amount to give to your dog. It is available in more recipes, too, and is actually a bit more affordable.