Below, we will discuss the comparison between two dog foods that offer grain-free formulas, which are Canidae vs Blue Buffalo. Many people believe that grain-free foods are better for dogs because dogs are basically carnivorous animals. They are supposed to eat meats. So, between these two dog foods, which one is better?
Continue reading below to learn more about:
– The ingredient quality of each dog food
– Whether they contain possibly harmful ingredients or not
– The comparison of their nutritional values
– The track record of Canidae vs Blue Buffalo
– Which dog food that is more recommended
Let’s start by taking a look at the ingredients of Canidae. This dog food has received lots of positive reviews because the ingredient quality is widely considered good. This dog food uses plenty of real meats and is enriched with some vegetables, vitamins, minerals, and probiotics that are highly beneficial for your dog. See also: Canidae vs Zignature.
The ingredients of Canidae that comes in the highest amounts include chicken, dried whole egg, menhaden fish meal, natural flavor, potatoes, peas, flaxseed, and lentils. Also, in smaller amounts, there are added vitamins, minerals, and some probiotics including dried Lactobacillus acidophilus fermentation product, dried Lactobacillus plantarum fermentation product, dried Lactobacillus casei fermentation product, dried Enterococcus faecium fermentation product, and dried Trichodermalongibrachiatum fermentation product.
The meat-based ingredients are very good. Chicken is an excellent source of protein and fat. Menhaden fish meal is rich in protein and omega-3 fatty acids. Eggs provide extremely high biological values. The vegetables are also good; dried alfalfa and peas provide some protein and fiber, lentils also provide fiber, and flaxseed is rich in protein and omega-3 fatty acids.
The added vitamins and minerals are very nice because they ensure that your dog gets complete, balanced nutrition. The probiotics will help to balance and maintain your dog’s digestive health while also guarding the immune system against possible pathogenic bacteria.
If we compare the nutritional values of Canidae vs Blue Buffalo, the favor is obviously on Canidae’s side. The Canidae dog food generally contains higher protein and fat. The differences are not huge, but this is still something to consider.
The guaranteed analysis values of Canidae are 30.6% crude protein, 15.1% crude fat, and 4.7% crude fiber. Meanwhile, on the dry matter basis, the dog food is estimated to have 33% protein, 13% fat, and 45% carbohydrate.
The overall nutrition profile is quite balanced. This dog food provides plenty of protein and fat, both of which are highly important for dogs. Proteins provide amino acids; there are twenty two different amino acids that your dog needs in order to survive, and ten of them can only be acquired from its diet. There are some fatty acids needed for various bodily functions.
Canidae: Recall History
When choosing a new dog food, it is important to check the track record of the company. You want to make sure that they do have good quality control. We can do some research to find out how many times that the company has recalled their products.
Canidae has only been recalled once. It was in 2012. The cause of the recall was salmonella contamination. However, the company hasn’t ever recalled their products since then. So, the quality control has improved.
Blue Buffalo: Ingredients
In general, both Canidae vs Blue Buffalo have good ingredient quality. Blue Buffalo also uses good quality meats and nutritious vegetables. However, Blue Buffalo has some ingredients that are somewhat controversial.
The first ingredients of Blue Buffalo are chicken, deboned salmon, dried egg, menhaden fish meal, fish oil, peas, pea protein, tapioca starch, dried tomato pomace, flaxseed, potatoes, dehydrated alfalfa meal, dried chicory root, and carrots. Other ingredients which come in smaller amounts include caramel color, added vitamins and minerals, dried yeast, dried Aspergillusniger fermentation product, dried Lactobacillus acidophilus fermentation product, dried Enterococcus faecium fermentation product, dried Trichodermalongibrachiatum fermentation product, and dried subtilis fermentation product.
As you can see, the meat-based ingredients are nice. Salmon, egg, menhaden dish meal, and chicken are rich in protein. In addition, menhaden fish meal and fish oil provide fatty acids that are needed for your dog’s bodily functions.
The vegetables are good. Most of these vegetables are to provide carbohydrate and dietary fiber. Although dogs require mostly protein and fat, they still need some carbohydrate and dietary fiber to grow and maintain ideal body shapes. Unfortunately, some of these plant-based ingredients, such as pea protein, flaxseed, and alfalfa meal, are high in protein. Plant-based proteins are not as good as meat-based ingredients for dogs.
Also, Blue Buffalo uses some filler. Tomato pomace is a by-product of the processing of tomatoes into juice, ketchup, and soup. It actually contains good amounts of fiber and some vitamins, but it is mostly considered as a cheap filler to increase a product’s nutritional values.
Blue Buffalo: Nutrition
Blue Buffalo generally provides good nutrition, but the nutritional values are not as high as Canidae’s. The differences are actually quite marginal. But, if you want to give the best nutrition that you can get for your dog, such small differences still matter.
The guaranteed analysis values of the Blue Buffalo dog food are 28.7% crude protein, 14.9% crude fat, and 7.0% crude fiber. Meanwhile, on the dry matter basis, this dog food is estimated to have 36% protein, 16% fat, and 41% carbohydrate.
The overall nutrition profile is good. This dog food provides balanced nutrition. It provides calories from carbohydrate, fat, and protein in more-or-less equal portions. The protein and fat levels are good although not as high as Canidae’s.
Blue Buffalo: Recall History
Blue Buffalo has been recalled at least 9 times. This fact may make us think twice about the quality control of the company.
It was recalled twice in 2007 because of melamine contamination. It was recalled once in 2010 because of toxic levels of vitamin D. In 2017, it was recalled three times because of a packaging problem, aluminum contamination, and elevated beef thyroid hormone. In 2016, it was recalled once because of mold. And in 2015, it was recalled twice because of propylene glycol presence and salmonella contamination.
Canidae vs Blue Buffalo
|- Great ingredient quality with excellent meat-based ingredients||- Good ingredient quality, but with plant-based proteins and filler|
|- Higher protein and fat||- Lower protein and fat|
|- Has been recalled only once in the past||- Has been recalled nine times in the past|
In general, Canidae is more recommended. This dog food has better ingredient quality. It provides better nutrition, with higher protein and fat. The company also has a better track record, as it has been recalled only once in the past.